top of page
Search

Copy of Why Employee Feedback Might Just Save Your Strategy (TPL Insights #272)

  • May 11
  • 6 min read

by Rob Andrews


Let me start with a truth bomb: If you’re not regularly asking your employees what’s working, what’s broken, and what’s downright maddening, you’re not leading—you’re guessing. And in today’s market, guessing is a luxury you can’t afford.


Too many leaders still think of employee feedback as that awkward annual HR ritual—“Tell us what you think in this 73-question survey… and we’ll get back to you sometime next fiscal year.” By the time the report hits your desk, the high performers you should’ve been listening to are already flirting with recruiters on LinkedIn.


Here’s the thing. Feedback isn’t just warm and fuzzy “employee engagement” fluff. It’s not an HR checkbox. It’s a high-leverage strategic asset—one of the fastest, cheapest, and most underused performance tools in your arsenal. Used well, it drives clarity, sharpens execution, and helps your team go from wandering generality to laser-focused force. Let’s talk about why.


Your Strategy Is Only as Good as Its Execution


You can spend six figures on strategy consultants, plaster your core values on every wall, and roll out a vision deck with all the right buzzwords… but if your people don’t understand it, believe in it, or see how their work connects to it? You’ve just created an expensive paperweight.


According to McKinsey & Company (2023), 70% of strategic transformations fail—mostly due to poor execution, not poor strategy. And the top reason for poor execution? Lack of employee understanding and alignment.


Want to fix that? Start with feedback. Real-time, on-the-ground, unfiltered insights from the people actually doing the work. Feedback is the organizational equivalent of sonar—it helps you detect obstacles and misalignments before you crash into them.


Feedback Creates Ownership (and That’s Half the Battle)


When employees feel heard, they start to act like owners. They notice things. They bring solutions. They give a damn.


Gallup (2022) found that employees who strongly agree they can give input and it will be acted on are four times more likely to be engaged. Engagement, in turn, drives performance, profitability, customer loyalty, and all those juicy outcomes CEOs like to brag about.


So if you want an army of problem-solvers instead of clock punchers, listen. Don’t just pretend to. Make it a habit. Build systems that close the loop and show people their input matters. And please—for the love of ROI—don’t make them wait a year for it.


The Frontline Sees What the Ivory Tower Can’t


Let’s get honest. Most senior leaders are at least one or two org-chart layers removed from reality. It’s not your fault. It just comes with the corner office and the badge-access-only espresso machine.


But your people? The ones in the field, on the phones, in the labs, or wrangling spreadsheets at 9:47 p.m.? They’re living the strategy, day in and day out. They know which processes are broken, which customers are fuming, and which parts of your master plan are pure corporate fiction.


Ignore them at your peril.


A study by HBR found that frontline employees often spot risks and innovation opportunities months before leadership (Beer et al., 2020). But when there’s no mechanism to share those insights—or when people are afraid to speak up—those insights die a quiet death.


Bad Leaders Fear Feedback. Great Ones Mine It for Gold.


Let’s not sugarcoat it. Feedback can be uncomfortable. Especially if it reveals that your strategy isn’t landing, your managers aren’t leading, or your change initiative is about as popular as a root canal.


But discomfort is the cost of growth.


Great leaders don’t run from feedback—they chase it down. They create safe spaces for honesty, reward dissenting views, and treat every comment as a clue to making the organization better, stronger, and faster.


As Ed Catmull, co-founder of Pixar, put it: “Candor is the key to collaboration. A hallmark of creative cultures is that people feel free to share their rough work—and their honest opinions—without fear” (Catmull & Wallace, 2014).


If Pixar can do it with billion-dollar movies, you can do it with your quarterly ops review.


Feedback Without Follow-Through is Just Lip Service


Here’s where most companies blow it.


They launch a flashy new feedback platform. They send out the surveys. They pat themselves on the back for being “people-first.” Then… crickets.


No action. No changes. No follow-up.


That’s worse than doing nothing.


Why? Because it trains your workforce to disengage. If feedback goes into a black hole, people learn that honesty is a waste of time—and they stop offering it. Trust erodes. Cynicism spreads. And before long, your culture starts to smell like resignation letters.


The fix? Build a closed-loop feedback system. Show employees you’re listening. Act on what you can. Explain what you can’t. And communicate constantly—up, down, and sideways.


So… How Do You Build a Feedback-Driven Organization?


Glad you asked. Here are a few practices we’ve installed in organizations moving from average to elite:


Pulse surveys that take <5 minutes to complete—and generate action in <5 days.

Monthly “Listen & Act” meetings where leaders tackle the top three employee pain points.

Skip-level check-ins where execs meet directly with frontline folks, no filter.

Transparent feedback dashboards so people see what’s changing and why.

Feedback training for managers to respond with curiosity, not defensiveness

Individual and Collective Mindset

Captures beliefs around optimism, growth, efficacy, and resilience. Examines whether employees believe their efforts make a difference and whether the organization encourages a “want to” rather than “have to” attitude.

The Degree to Which the Senior Leadership Team Is Aligned

Measures Unified Leadership: alignment around purpose, mission, vision, values, and strategy; congruent leadership messaging; and mutual support among senior leaders​.

The Degree to Which Leadership Messages Are Being Received by Frontline Employees

Assesses perceived clarity and consistency of leadership communication and whether frontline employees sense alignment and unity among leaders​.

Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)

Gauges likelihood of employees recommending the company as a great place to work (not directly cited in the report but part of the broader measurement structure).

Execution of Strategy Aligned with Purpose, Mission, Vision, and Values

Evaluates whether the strategy is anchored in core purpose and values, as shown in the “Purpose Driven Approach” and “Measure What Matters” sections​.

The Degree to Which the Company Is Experiencing Its Stated Vision

Gap analysis between current and vision culture (Index scores: 538 current vs. 843 vision = 305-point gap) indicates how closely the current culture mirrors the aspirational culture​.

Strength of Market Positioning and Business Development Efforts

Inferred from clarity in purpose and mission, as well as external stakeholder feedback loops and onboarding aligned with values​.

Customer Experience Differentiation and Strength

Customer Experience score assesses behaviors like valuing complaints, empowering employees, and ensuring return business by making customers feel valued​.

Balanced Stakeholder Engagement evaluates how well the company involves employees, customers, suppliers, and shareholders in creating shared value and driving profitability

And no, it’s not about making everyone happy. It’s about making the organization smarter, faster, and more capable of executing on its biggest priorities.


The Bottom Line: Feedback = Fuel


Here’s the deal: Strategy without feedback is like sailing without a compass. You might move fast, but you won’t know where you’re headed—or when you’re off course.


If you want to lead a peak-performing culture, don’t just ask for feedback. Obsess over it. Systematize it. Celebrate it. Build it into your DNA. It might not be sexy. It might not fit neatly into a spreadsheet. But it’s the fastest way to align your strategy with reality—and your people with your purpose. And if that sounds like too much work? Well… enjoy the sound of crickets at your next town hall.


As always, I hope this material is helpful. Let us know if we can be your thought partner.



Rob Andrews


Chairman & Chief Executive Officer


Celebrating 28 years of Executive Search, Executive Coaching & Culture Shaping Excellence


Direct: 713.489.9724/ Mobile: 713.301.6130


4801 Woodway Dr., Suite 130W, Houston, TX, 77056


www.allenaustin.com Link to Allen Austin Overview


Link to Total Performance Leadership Overview


References


Beer, M., Finnström, M., & Schrader, D. (2020). Why leaders don’t listen to employee feedback. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2020/03/why-leaders-dont-listen-to-employee-feedback


Catmull, E., & Wallace, A. (2014). Creativity, Inc.: Overcoming the unseen forces that stand in the way of true inspiration. Random House.



 
 
bottom of page